source : the age
The state government has settled its case with a grieving father kept in hotel quarantine after his daughter’s death just as a Supreme Court trial was set to begin.
Hong Kong-based lawyer Hayden Flinn had filed a lawsuit against the state and its Health Department for damages, claiming he had been unnecessarily detained for two weeks after flying home to bury his 13-year-old daughter following her sudden death in Melbourne in May 2021.
At the time, the world was a year into the COVID-19 pandemic and Flinn said he was subjected to “indignity and insult”, a loss of liberty and mental distress when he was refused an exemption on compassionate grounds.
What followed, he said, was a distressing two weeks locked in a small Richmond hotel room with his devastated teenage son after the pair were refused permission to quarantine with family at home.
Flinn said he was also barred from viewing his daughter’s body and could not be with his distressed wife as she planned their child’s funeral.
On Tuesday, as the 10-day trial was due to begin, Justice Andrew Keogh was told that the parties had reached a settlement agreement.
The court heard there were still “T’s to cross and I’s to dot”, with the matter to return on Thursday if anything needed to be addressed.
“I congratulate the parties,” Keogh said.
On Sunday, this masthead revealed that the corporate lawyer, who is now co-chief executive of a large Hong Kong law firm, argued he should never have been detained, with officials failing to properly assess his personal circumstances, vaccination status and the low risk presented by travellers from Hong Kong.
Lawyers for the state and Health Department had denied any wrongdoing, maintaining their decision-making was reasonable and justified, and that Flinn had chosen to remain in quarantine.
At the time of Flinn’s return, there were no lockdowns in Victoria or reported community transmission of the virus.
The judge-alone trial was set to hear from a string of witnesses including former chief health officer Brett Sutton and his deputy, Allen Cheng, about the decision-making process around the Flinns’ case and other exemptions given during the pandemic.
But emails revealed a Health Department email, sent on May 4, 2021, read: “The level of distress being experienced by the family was assessed as too high for the family to maintain [detention] requirements. The alternative of going home to wife and family would pose a COVID-19 risk to family and public health.”
There were no lockdowns in Victoria or reported community transmission of the virus at the time of Flinn’s return.
Be the first to know when major news happens. Sign up for our breaking news alerts on email or turn on notifications in the app.
