Home National Australia A grieving father took on the government over hotel quarantine. He’s not...

A grieving father took on the government over hotel quarantine. He’s not keeping a cent of the settlement

5
0

source : the age

Once every three months, Hayden Flinn sits down to dinner with four other fathers who have all lost a child. He carries a membership to a club he never wished to join – one that has changed his life forever.

They speak about youth mental health and of grief and of ways to make the world a better place for the young people of the future.

Flinn knows pain, having lost his young teenage daughter suddenly in May 2021 following her battle with mental health. But the Hong Kong-based corporate lawyer says he also knows injustice when he sees it.

Hayden Flinn and his wife Dr Sarah Whorlow.Simon Schluter

This week, he took the Victorian government to the Supreme Court and won a confidential settlement on the eve of a 10-day trial, claiming he had been unlawfully detained in hotel quarantine for two weeks after his 13-year-old girl died in Melbourne during the coronavirus pandemic.

At the time, in May 2021, there were no local transmissions in Melbourne and the country he was travelling from was not on the government list of virus danger zones.

When he landed in Melbourne, Flinn, a co-chief executive of a large Hong Kong law firm, was bussed to a small Richmond hotel room with his teenage son after the pair were refused permission to quarantine at home with family.

Flinn filed a lawsuit against the state and its Health Department in 2024, claiming he had been unnecessarily detained for two weeks when he was subjected to indignity and insult, a loss of liberty and mental distress when he was refused an exemption to hotel quarantine on compassionate grounds.

At a time when he says he should have been viewing his daughter’s body and helping his wife plan the funeral, he was trapped in hotel quarantine. He argued he should never have been detained, with officials failing to properly assess his personal circumstances, vaccination status and the low risk presented by travellers from Hong Kong.

“It was a difficult time,” he told this masthead.

Alex King, partner at King and Collins law firm, estimates the state would have spent in excess of $2 million in taxpayer funds defending its case had the case gone to court.

When he met Flinn for the first time, King recalls coming across a meticulously prepared father, who arrived at King’s office with an abundance of material.

“The one thing that struck me with Hayden is, sometimes you have a conference with a client and to be frank, you don’t need to prepare that much. Whenever you have a conference with Hayden you have to prepare because you know he’ll be better prepared, and that’s not a good look,” King says.

“That became a feature and … really just showed me Hayden was completely resolute and driven about this case.

“There seemed to be this unquenchable, inexhaustible fire behind all of this which probably came from a number of sources but one of them was … the large expatriate community in Hong Kong, I think about 100,000 people. Hayden would say to me that it had been said to him, ‘if you can’t do this, who can?’.”

But what followed, King says, was stonewalling from government departments, including those that manage freedom of information requests.

COVID-19 testing at Melbourne’s showgrounds in 2020.Bloomberg

“We realised we then had to move fairly quickly because of the three-year limitations period on bringing a tort of false imprisonment. There was a lack of public information, and while Hayden had started digging around, governments are like vaults, they just won’t give stuff away, notwithstanding the FOI [freedom of information] regimes,” King says.

“There was an enormous amount of work done over that ensuing year that when he did a lot of FOI requests to Commonwealth and Victorian agencies, we were continually rebuffed.”

King says when the government’s pleadings were finally filed, they revealed the decision by then-chief health officer Brett Sutton to hold Flinn in hotel quarantine had never even been written down.

If it were not for Flinn’s discipline and courage and energy to uncover the truth, King says the state might never have settled, pausing to acknowledge it was a massive enterprise to take on the government, with the loser of court proceedings facing the prospect of paying both parties’ legal costs.

Passengers disembark from a chartered flight from Uruguay after being evacuated off the coronavirus-stricken Greg Mortimer cruise ship.Getty

“In court proceedings for false imprisonment, the usual position is wanting money in damages for that false imprisonment. As part of his settlement with the state, though, Hayden sought no financial compensation. He did not want a dollar for his pocket,” King says.

What he wanted, King says, was justice. Flinn is donating every cent received from the government to help young people struggling with mental health.

For Flinn’s wife Sarah Whorlow, 2021 is a time she struggles to talk about. Battling to get her husband out of hotel quarantine to be with his grieving family was horrific, she says.

She hopes her family can now focus on helping other families in need and spreading awareness of youth mental health.

“[I was] needing to deal with coroners and police and funeral homes and cemeteries while he was locked up, that was very challenging,” she says.

“I don’t think Hayden could’ve got through all of this without … the support … of friends and lawyers.”

In a statement signed by Secretary of Health Jenny Atta, seen by this masthead, she says the state regrets the impact that mandatory hotel quarantine had on Flinn’s family, but denies any allegation of wrongdoing.

“The state acknowledges that Mr Flinn’s detention caused him and his family significant personal distress and regrets this,” Atta says.

“At Mr Flinn’s request, the state has agreed to make a monetary contribution to be used by Mr Flinn for charitable purposes focussing on Victorian youth mental health.”

Hugh de Kretser, the president of the Australian Human Rights Commission, thanked Flinn for bringing his case and ensuring some accountability for the detention decisions that impacted many others in similar circumstances.

“Your actions will help to ensure a more compassionate and humane response to future public health emergencies,” de Kretser says.

Flinn and Whorlow plan to now take some time to find the right charity for them, one they hope to work with long term and where they can share their own lived experience of youth mental health when the time feels right.

They also hope to bring attention to better solutions for helping children in mental health crisis, rather than busy, bright and loud emergency departments like those that their daughter visited before she died.

A close family friend, who asked not to be named, says there remains a generation of young people who lost their social networks during the pandemic and who are finding it difficult to rebuild those.

“What is disturbing is the number of suicides that are happening in the community and they’re getting younger. It’s the leading cause of death in people aged 15 to 24 in Australia, and I think it astounds most people,” Flinn says.

Kids Helpline: 1800 55 1800; Lifeline: 13 11 14

Start the day with a summary of the day’s most important and interesting stories, analysis and insights. Sign up for our Morning Edition newsletter.