SOURCE :- SIASAT NEWS
Hyderabad: The Telangana High Court has issued a set of guidelines regulating how police open, continue and close rowdy sheets, making it clear that simply having a rowdy sheet against a person does not give police the right to repeatedly summon them to the police station, restrict their movement or harass them.
It observed that police surveillance is meant to prevent crime and maintain public order, not to punish or humiliate a person.
It clarified that maintaining a rowdy sheet alone cannot be a reason for repeatedly calling someone to a police station, forcing them to attend, restricting their movement, interfering with their work or publicly humiliating them. Any such action must have a separate legal basis and follow the procedure prescribed by law.
However, the court clarified that these guidelines do not prevent police from exercising their lawful powers to prevent crime.
Rules towards rowdy sheeters
Hearing both sides’ arguments, the Telangana High Court has laid down the following guidelines for the state police.
Verification of Eligibility: The Station House Officer (SHO) would be required to independently verify whether an individual falls under Standing Order 601 by the police. Mere registration of first FIRs (first information reports) or isolated criminal cases cannot justify opening a rowdy sheet.
Reasoned Proposals: The SHO must submit detailed proposals specifying the applicable category, case outcomes, and material establishing ‘habituality’ and the necessity for surveillance.
Independent Approval: Senior officers must not mechanically approve SHO recommendations. They must record specific reasons for authorising the opening of a rowdy sheet.
Comprehensive Review: Before renewal, the SHO must undertake a fresh assessment, specifically recording if the individual has been an accused in any case in the preceding five years, the date of the last crime, and material indicating if victims are unwilling to complain.
Periodic Review: Renewal proposals must distinguish between the material that led to the original opening of the sheet and subsequent material justifying its continuation. Mere repetition of old cases or general apprehensions will not suffice. Acquittals, discharges, compromises, closure reports and other forms of termination of criminal proceedings shall be duly considered.
Disposal of Rowdy Sheet Deletion requests: Representations seeking deletion of names from rowdy sheets should be disposed of by a reasoned order, preferably within six weeks of receipt. Any representation seeking deletion of an individual’s name from a rowdy sheet shall be objectively examined.
Supervisory scrutiny and discontinuance: The Commissioners of Police and Superintendents of Police concerned shall ensure the implementation of these directions through their supervisory officers and periodically scrutinise the rowdy sheets maintained in their respective jurisdictions, particularly those continued for prolonged periods or in respect of individuals against whom no criminal case has been registered during the preceding five years.
Case that led to guidelines
The court passed the order while allowing a petition filed by a city businessman who challenged the continued surveillance of him by the Chatrinaka Police Station.
The petitioner told the court that police opened a rowdy sheet against his client in 2008 based on a criminal case. However, his name continued to remain on the list for nearly 18 years without sufficient reasons.
He pointed out that continued police surveillance, repeated visits to the police station and the social stigma attached to being labelled a rowdy sheeter affected his fundamental rights, including his right to equality and personal liberty under Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution.
He has repeatedly requested the police to remove his name from the rowdy sheet, but the requests were not accepted.
The state counsel, appearing for the police, argued that the petitioner had been involved in seven criminal cases, and people were hesitant to lodge complaints against him out of fear.
SOURCE : SIASAT



