source : the age
When Premier Chris Minns announced new underquoting laws a year ago, making it harder for agents to manipulate buyer interest, it was touted as one of the largest reforms to the real estate industry in decades.
But just hours before the reforms to restore trust and transparency were due to take effect, the premier pulled the pin because concerns were raised by real estate agents in his local Kogarah electorate.
The 11th-hour turnaround has wasted millions of dollars and countless hours of industry training. It has also done nothing to instil trust and transparency in the state government’s legislative ability.
The only winners from Minns’ shock announcement on Monday night are the thousands of real estate agents who have made a profession out of underquoting on auction price guides.
Just ask former star sales gun Josh Tesolin, who was slapped with a decade-long ban from the industry and fines of $33,000 after he was found to have engaged in sustained unlawful, improper and dishonest conduct on more than 100 property transactions.
As revealed by this masthead’s Bidding Blind investigation, almost half of all property sales across the state sell at auction for more than 10 per cent above the guide. Sydney is the underquoting capital of Australia.
As part of the 18-month investigation by The Sydney Morning Herald and The Age, there was an overwhelming response from more than 9100 people who reported widespread and blatant underquoting across Victoria and NSW. The majority of them had spent time and money investigating the purchase of properties that they were ultimately unable to afford.
Following those findings, the Minns government’s proposed reforms included new rules that made it mandatory to include price guides on all marketing and information for buyers based on three comparable sales. Penalties were also set to increase from $22,000 to $110,000 or three times an agent’s commission, whichever is greater. These are all sensible, considered reforms.
But in the fine print was a restriction on any price advisement below a written offer that had been previously rejected.
That isn’t an issue in a rising market, but is a problem in a falling market given sellers cannot revise their price down if they previously rejected a higher offer in writing.
The government was warned multiple times before the legislation was passed in June that it could have unintended consequences.
Better Regulation and Fair Trading minister Anoulack Chanthivong finally got the memo on Monday when he admitted the laws were passed “at a different time and in a different economic and housing market”.
In other words, the laws were not fit for purpose.
Meanwhile, real estate companies and agents have been left reeling from the last-minute change of plan.
It’s not just agents on the ground who were set to update their marketing with price guides from midnight. Dan White, the head of Australia’s largest real estate franchise, Ray White Group, said members have spent considerable time, effort and energy learning these reforms and amending their business practices.
“Over the past six months, our compliance team has run sessions with all 3400 of our NSW members,” White said. “We hired halls from Yamba to Orange to hold zone meetings across the state.”
In response to the Bidding Blind investigation, Ray White also built Stockboard, a real-time compliance platform, where residential sales across the group are scanned and flagged if a listing doesn’t meet underquoting requirements.
The platform is already operating across Victoria, where reforms were rolled out in October mandating an advertised reserve price a week ahead of all auctions.
As buyers front up to auctions across Sydney in coming weeks, they may well be looking for someone to blame for the failed policy rollout.
For now, Minns has Chanthivong’s back, declaring his full confidence in the fair trading minister on Tuesday despite industry calls for his dismissal.
At least buyers will get a chance to voice their concerns, much like the real estate agents of Kogarah, at the state election in March.
Start the day with a summary of the day’s most important and interesting stories, analysis and insights. Sign up for our Morning Edition newsletter.
