Home Latest Australia ‘My word against a dead guy’s’: murder accused’s call

‘My word against a dead guy’s’: murder accused’s call

5
0

Source : Perth Now news

A would-be thief confronted by a prominent doctor during a home invasion allegedly fatally struck him with a metal bar embedded with a drill bit.

Michael Yung, 61, the former head of the pediatric intensive care unit at Adelaide’s Women’s and Children’s Hospital, was found with critical head injuries in his Gilberton home in 2023.

Kerem Aydin, 25, is on trial in the South Australian Supreme Court, accused of murdering the doctor during a break-in in the Yung family home in Adelaide’s inner north in the early hours of December 11.

Aydin was allegedly later recorded saying it would be “my word against a dead guy’s”.

“There’s evidence in this case that goes some way to talking for the dead guy,” prosecutor Jim Pearce KC said in his opening address on Monday.

Aydin, who has pleaded not guilty, went to Dr Yung’s home at 4.15am and used a ladder to break into a spare bedroom after CCTV had recorded him conducting reconnaissance on the home.

The accused man had been facing eviction because of unpaid rent on the home in Thebarton he shared with his partner and young child, Mr Pearce said.

Ronan Yung is expected to tell the court he was woken by his father’s voice and went downstairs.

There, he found his father lying on the dining room floor and rang triple zero.

Aydin had smashed through doors and fled, after twice striking Dr Yung in the head with a 30-centimetre metal bar with a drill bit wedged into its end, causing two “punch-out” skull fractures, Mr Pearce alleged.

“The weapon penetrated not just the scalp and the skull, but also penetrated into the brain, causing catastrophic injuries, from which Dr Yung ultimately died,” the prosecutor said.

A third blow to the torso caused significant internal bleeding.

The weapon was later found behind a high brick fence at a nearby property.

Police obtained DNA from blood samples from two torches and a blood trail and, by December 12, had a working theory that Aydin was the perpetrator, Mr Pearce said.

He was arrested at a supermarket that day and had obvious injuries.

In conversations with social workers, and recorded phone calls with friends and family, Aydin’s story of what happened in Dr Yung’s home changed, Mr Pearce said.

In a call to his mother, he said he believed the home was a deceased estate, and he had asked Dr Yung for $50 and to “just let me go home”.

“He … has taken me downstairs to the kitchen, he has gone for a knife … (and) I’ve just reacted,” Aydin allegedly told his mother.

In a phone call from prison to a friend, Aydin said “it was his word against a dead guy.”

“What he doesn’t say in those calls is that I struck him over the head with a weapon, and I did it twice, then I also struck him to the torso,” Mr Pearce said.

“Picking up on the accused’s analysis … there’s evidence in this case that goes some way to talking for the dead guy, and it concerns the nature of the weapon.”

A knife block on the kitchen bench was missing one knife, but police found it in the dishwasher, he said.

Aydin is also charged with aggravated serious criminal trespass in a place of residence.

Jane Abbey KC, for Aydin, said the trial’s two primary issues would be causation and intent.

There was no dispute that her client scoped out property, that he intended to break in to commit theft, and that Dr Yung confronted him and they had a conversation, she said.

“But Mr Aydin did not cause his death and certainly didn’t at any stage hold murderous intent,” she said.

“We intend putting … a clear alternate hypothesis consistent with Mr Aydin’s innocence.”

The trial before Chief Justice Laura Stein continues.