Home Latest Australia Robert Crawford murder trial: Defence delivers closing address, blames police for biasing...

Robert Crawford murder trial: Defence delivers closing address, blames police for biasing investigation

3
0

Source : Perth Now news

A former high-flying pilot’s defence team has blamed a police officer for biasing a murder investigation before properly examining the scene of his wife’s death.

The murder trial of former RAAF man Robert Crawford, accused of killing his wife Frances Crawford in July 2024, will soon reach its conclusion, with his defence giving their closing address to the jury on Wednesday.

Mr Crawford is accused of murdering his wife at their Upper Lockyer home west of Brisbane and staging the scene to look like she had tipped a lawnmower over a retaining wall, becoming trapped underneath.

He has pleaded not guilty to the crime.

The prosecution alleges Mr Crawford instead strangled his wife and staged the scene, not wanting to lose a lucrative $5.4m fortune in a potential divorce after Ms Crawford uncovered about 20 years of his infidelity.

Barrister Saul Holt KC began his address by claiming Mr Crawford had come upon his wife following a “tragic accident”.

“She died on a ride-on lawnmower accident at the foot of a rock wall at her own home,” he told the jury.

“When jigsawing is done, a picture does emerge.

“It is a picture of an accident.

“It is as simple and tragic as that.”

Robert Crawford is accused of killing his wife Frances and staging her death to appear like an accident. Supplied Credit: NewsWire

He argued the jury had been presented with a “mountain of evidence, much of which (was) barely relevant”.

“Not only is this a circumstantial question, it is in truth one of the weakest circumstantial cases you will ever see in court,” Mr Holt claimed.

“A lot of evidence does not equal good evidence.”

Mr Holt warned the jury to be aware of “hindsight reasoning”.

“Once you have decided that something is a murder, everything become a clue,” he suggested.

“Are these the words of a man who is covering something up or are these the words of a man who didn’t.

“A love note becomes a prop … Robert Crawford doing CPR becomes an ‘actor’ … grief in its purest form becomes ‘crocodile tears’.”

Sergeant Glen Thomas was present at the Crawford home in regards to a domestic dispute a year before Ms Crawford’s death. Picture: NewsWire / John Gass
Sergeant Glen Thomas was present at the Crawford home in regards to a domestic dispute a year before Ms Crawford’s death. NewsWire / John Gass Credit: News Corp Australia

Mr Holt claimed the idea was planted in investigators’ minds as a result of first responding officer Sergeant Glen Thomas’ comments.

During the trial, the court heard evidence Sergeant Thomas had attended the home a year before Ms Crawford’s death for a domestic dispute after Mr Crawford allegedly broke into the home and confronted the family.

He had been kicked out of the home, with Ms Crawford changing the locks, after she had discovered his illicit affairs.

“(Murder claims) came from Sergeant Thomas,” Mr Holt said.

“He grossly exaggerated what happened the year before and everybody listened.

“(Sergeant Thomas told others) this is a man who broke in with an axe, kicked in the door and she was cowering in her room.

“Before anyone has looked at anything, this is apparently a staged scene.

“He tells everyone who will listen there are red flags everywhere.

“None of it was true.”

He argued police were driven to look for signs of a murder, rather than look at the scene objectively.

“I don’t have any criticism for Sergeant Thomas taking domestic violence seriously,” Mr Holt said.

“But a conclusion has come first and everything has followed.”

The trial continues.

If you or someone you know is experiencing family violence, phone 1800 RESPECT (1800 737 732) or the Crisis Care Helpline on 1800 199 008.

DOWNLOAD THE NIGHTLY APP