Home National Australia Minor parties with major issues

Minor parties with major issues

5
0

source : the age

Badiucao

To submit a letter to The Age, email letters@theage.com.au. Please include your home address and telephone number below your letter. No attachments. See here for our rules and tips on getting your letter published.

DEMOCRACY

I am deeply distressed to realise that there is trickery and dishonesty at the heart of the Victorian election system. How is it fair that there are three ″⁣political parties″⁣ on the ballot papers that attempt to deceive the naive or unwary voter by having a deceptive name? The three ″⁣parties″⁣ are Climate Action Now, Free Palestine and I’m Voting to Avoid the Fine. All three are part of a purported campaign to funnel preferences to One Nation.
I would never vote for One Nation, but at least they are upfront about their policies and values. Climate Action Now is expected to funnel any votes to One Nation, which believes climate change is a hoax. Free Palestine means freeing Israel from Hamas, which may be fair enough, but is not the commonly accepted meaning of this slogan and therefore deceptive. I’m Voting To Avoid the Fine sounds apolitical, but it is suspected of being a front for One Nation.
Sue Fisher, Coburg

Rural kids deserve same chances as city kids
With the state election just days away, regional families are watching with growing alarm as cuts to Disability Inclusion funding threaten vital classroom support in 2027.
For the past 2 years, my son has attended Warracknabeal Special Development School as a non-standard enrolment, meaning the school received no individualised Disability Inclusion funding to support him. He was finally granted funding this year – only for us to learn that student-level funding rates are now being cut by 2.5 per cent, alongside a narrower assessment tool and an $850-per-term cut for thousands of mainstream students.
In a small country specialist school, there is no giant financial buffer to absorb cuts while covering rising staffing costs under the 2026 enterprise agreement. Every dollar goes straight to the education support staff, therapists, and teachers who keep our kids safe and help them learn.
Our rural kids deserve the same chance to thrive as children in Melbourne. Before Saturday, November 28, local candidates must tell regional parents whether they will reverse these cuts.
Rae Crow, parent and president, Warracknabeal Special Development School Council, Warracknabeal

Could there be a more heartless election policy?
Is the Liberal Party serious about rescinding the Treaty that the current state government negotiated with First Nation citizens? Since the arrival of whitefellas in the late 18th century, we have progressively deprived our Aboriginal community of their lands, their culture, their languages and their theology. It took nearly 200 years before they were recognised as belonging to our nation.
Now, with the ink barely dry on the Treaty, the possible next government is vowing to shred it. Could there be a more heartless governmental policy?
Ross Corben, Knoxfield

Sponging off us to make fortunes
The proliferation of data centres makes me angry. They use up enormous amounts of water and power. That infrastructure was paid for with our taxes, water and electricity bills. Now data centres want to sponge off us to make themselves billions.
What will happen during the next major drought? Will data centres be required to reduce their water use like we do? If there is an electricity outage, will they have their supplies restored before us?
I am sick of governments preferencing data centres ahead of us.
Pauline Ashton, Maribyrnong

Blaming migrants not billionaires
I loved MattD’s cartoon ″⁣Voter vox pop: hard questions, hardly answered″⁣ (Letters, 20/11) as it summed up succinctly who has all the wealth in this country – billionaires. Yet, when it comes to solving our current cost of living problems, it’s the fault of the migrants.
Figure that out.
Marisa Di Giacomo, Beaumaris

THE FORUM

CBD crimes
I’m compelled to write after the tragic stabbing that occurred at the Melbourne GPO over the weekend. On Thursday, we visited the same area with our two grandbabies to see the Myer windows. There was a group of clearly mentally unwell and substance-affected people all sleeping rough on the steps of the GPO, and the area smelt heavily of urine.
Sadly, I was unsurprised by the stabbing because we are not managing a developing crisis in the CBD nor in our community where negligible resources and lack of management of these issues spells disaster. Is this really the Melbourne we have become?
Anne Dive, Kensington

Falling crime rate
Thank you to the former head of criminology at Monash University for his letter (22/11) on the falling crime rate in Victoria. It must be infuriating for the new police chief commissioner and the police themselves to see the way in which crime has been weaponised by some politicians and media outlets in recent times.
One has only to take time to look closely into the crime statistics with the data showing a fall in criminal and other incidents, to understand there is a substantial decline in overall crime rates in Victoria, including youth offending.
We should be thanking the police and all those government employees who work in the justice areas and youth justice, for their hard work and dedication and successes so far. Not weaponising crime with ‘blatant misinformation and fake news’, and making out that nothing has been achieved.
Julie Chandler, Blairgowrie

Crime and education
Labor and the Coalition are competing over who will be tougher on crime in Victoria. Bail refusals and revocations at record highs, pushing more children into detention, apparently reflects effective reform.
However, the correlation between poverty, family disadvantage, poor education outcomes and youth crime is seldom raised. Australia has one of the most segregated and inequitable education systems in the developed world, with Victorian schools the lowest funded in Australia.
Some of those schools produce impressive results, but too many Victorian students are not getting a fair go, and our system is an impediment to the social cohesion desperately needed today.
The Greens appear to be genuinely committed to equality of educational opportunities regardless of family income or background, and this will attract some of those traditional Labor voters who are abandoning ship.
Norman Huon, Port Melbourne

It’s time to grow
Millie Muroi’s insightful article (″⁣The government can improve its own productivity – and it should″⁣, 21/11) hits the nail on the head. This is precisely the proactive, constructive mindset we must adopt and implement if we are to reverse three decades of stagnant construction productivity. Let’s get on with it.
Brian Marshall, Ashburton

Better than nothing COP
The value of the annual global climate talks is questioned every year, and COP31 is no exception (“Hot air or helping: Are global climate talks working?“, 21/11). As your correspondent notes, “vested fossil fuel and political interests have hamstrung real action” (Letters, “Climate options”, 22/11).
There’s no denying the hypocrisy, or the frustration at the fanfare and grandstanding surrounding many leaders’ appearances. But imagine if there were no COP at all. Where would that leave us as the climate crisis escalates?
At the very least, this year’s talks have shone a spotlight on the Albanese government’s continued support for coal and gas expansion, built momentum for electrification, and consolidated the group of countries pushing for a phase out of fossil fuels. A flawed table is better than no table at all.
Amy Hiller, Kew

Call out despots
The hypocrisy demonstrated by our so-called ‘world leaders’ is mind boggling. They speak of peace, limiting nukes and so on, yet continue to act in the opposite manner. It is the old ‘mushroom strategy’. Putin continues to say he wants peace while he sends waves of missiles into Ukraine.
Trump is no different. He started a war against Iran, threatens Cuba and Venezuela, and yet pre-election, claimed he would end the war between Russia and Ukraine within 24 hours and would not lead America into another war.
Xi Jing Ping continues to threaten countries in the region of the South China Sea while expanding China’s military capacity.
Time for all to get angry and call out these power-hungry despots. The media’s role in this is vital.
Charles Griss, Balwyn

Matthew Flinders’ day
July 18 should be Australia Day (“Explorer’s rare 1804 prison letter”, 22/11) as the anniversary of the publication of Matthew Flinders’ account of his circumnavigation of the Australian continent and the popularisation of the name of Australia instead of New Holland for the continent. January 26 could just remain as Invasion Day.
Wayne Robinson, Kingsley WA

Normalised abuse
Re ″⁣Joanne Young was drugged and raped for years. Now Britain confronts her calls for change″⁣, 22/11). Young’s courage to waive her anonymity to pursue full legal accountability against her husband and the men who raped her exposes an uncomfortable truth: this type of offending is no longer an aberration, but rather part of an increasingly visible pattern of drug-facilitated sexual violence in which technology has become a powerful tool for the planning and normalisation of abuse among like-minded offenders.
That the four men convicted last Thursday argued they were ″⁣conned″⁣ into believing Young’s husband could consent on her behalf to their sexual abuse of her, beggars belief. Not least of which because both in the UK and Australia, courts repudiated
the legal fiction of irrevocable marital consent more than three decades ago.
Perhaps the real question is not whether consent laws require further reform, but whether greater limits should be placed on the invocation of rape myths in criminal proceedings by defence counsel. And, recognising that organised, digitally facilitated sexual violence may be far more prevalent than previously understood.
Jelena Rosic, Mornington

Dining out jitters
The interesting article about restaurants beginning to offer smaller (and healthier) meals to accommodate people on weight loss medication misses one blindingly obvious point.
Large helpings in restaurants and pubs are a major cause of the population’s obesity. They also create unnecessary food waste. Of course, people eat at home too, but public eating places can be controlled by legislation.
When eating out it is very difficult to ask for smaller meals, and adults are generally not ‘allowed’ to have children’s size meals (some friendly restaurants do allow this if you ask). I have a small appetite, and being faced with an overflowing plate is very unpleasant, yet I have quite often been told, ″⁣Just leave what you don’t want″⁣.
Too often, wait staff ask if the food was OK, if you leave some. It makes eating out quite nerve-racking. I have always been astonished that portion control isn’t part of the government’s response to obesity; restaurants should be obliged to offer smaller servings as an alternative.
Erica Smith, Newington

Home birth option
Rachel Rasker’s article “Midwives fear upcoming rule changes will push more women to unqualified doulas” (21/11) implies that women who cannot plan a home birth due to unavailability of midwives are forced to deliver alone without a trained birth attendant. This is false.
Australia has a safe and free maternity service for anyone with Medicare cover so those who decide not to use this are making an informed choice.
This issue has arisen due to changes in funding for private home birth midwives’ indemnity insurance. Regulators are obliged to ensure all professionals carry such cover. Things can suddenly go wrong with any birth, and it is not fair to all other doctors and midwives if home birth practitioners are exempt from such insurance.
Home birth is an option for appropriately triaged families and programs are available from some maternity hospitals but are labour intensive and expensive.
Dr Jenny Dowd, Ivanhoe East

Cricket’s mummy issues
I think that dealing openly, honestly and well with Sandpapergate may help Australia grow up. Test cricket has colonial origins, and the Australian team still carries the flag (with its Union Jack).
Australian cricket is inseparable from Australia’s relationship with England, which for so long has been parent and child. Arguably, Cricket Australia’s panicked reaction to the affair was to demonstrate to ‘mother’ that her ‘son’ is such a good boy he will punish himself.
In other words, the relationship is shame-based rather than reality-based – we have to show we are doing the right thing, even if we are not. We can make the relationship far more real by openly admitting that Australians cheat and lie, just like every other human individual and society.
It’s time to give up the ‘good boy’ image, Australia.
David Champion, Ivanhoe

AND ANOTHER THING

Trump world
Re Letters (″⁣Discordant trio″⁣, 21/11) I think the Three Terrors would be a good name for Vladimir Putin, Donald Trump and Xi Jinping.
Sandra Torpey, Hawthorn

Why do I look at Trump and his actions and am reminded so much of Henry VIII?
Winston Anderson, Mornington

Is it naivety or extreme narcissism that prevents Trump from realising he was played by Xi and Putin – enemies of the US. How much more damage does the world have to tolerate from the Trump regime?
Yvonne Trevaskis, Hobart

Jacqueline Maley (22/11) describes Donald Trump’s secretary of war, Pete Hegseth as his war Barbie. Close, but not quite. He’s more like a war Ken. Take the pants off, and there’s not much there.
Philip West, Jan Juc

Furthermore
Public servants have good reason to feel nervous about their job security (″⁣Staff in limbo″⁣, 22/11). When the Liberals are elected, the first to go are public servants. However, the reality is not much is saved because consultants are engaged to fill the gap, usually at inflated rates. Sad thing is experience and loyalty of permanents is lost.
Dan Drummond, Leongatha

Unanswered questions. Who handed the sandpaper to Cameron Bancroft? Who approved it? Where did it come from? Why was Bancroft singled out? Why him?
Susan Rodwell, Drouin

Please, time to bury collective heads in the sand and move on. Eight years later and important stuff is actually happening in the world.
Maggie Durinck, Ferntree Gully

To those who have bought an EV, your hip pocket and planet Earth, thank you!
Greg Curtin, Nunawading

For somebody who heads up an organisation that is required to work in clandestine ways, Mike Burgess has crafted an extremely high profile.
Mark Hulls, Sandringham

The opinion newsletter is a weekly wrap of views that will challenge, champion and inform your own. Sign up here.